• 29055 Clemens Road Westlake, Ohio 44145, United States
  • Mon - Fri 8:00AM - 6:00PM EST
Appointment

Initiate a Consultation

We invite employers and vendors who are uncompromising about the impact of their healthcare plans to schedule a strategic conversation.

Appointment

Initiate a Consultation

We invite employers and vendors who are uncompromising about the impact of their healthcare plans to schedule a strategic conversation.

Share:

The High Price Of Keeping Employees Quiet thumbnail

The High Price Of Keeping Employees Quiet

An employer may tolerate a 20% increase in healthcare costs just to avoid a few employee complaints. But how many employees are quietly paying the price for that silence every payday? James Farley | J.P.Farley …

An employer may tolerate a 20% increase in healthcare costs just to avoid a few employee complaints. But how many employees are quietly paying the price for that silence every payday?

There is a peculiar fear in corporate healthcare that I have encountered throughout my career. An employer may be perfectly willing to discuss rising medical costs, expensive hospital contracts, unnecessary procedures, and the possibility of saving a substantial amount of money. But suggest changing the health plan, and the conversation often turns to one concern:

What will the employees say?

Employee complaints, or what we sometimes call “employee noise”, have become a powerful influence on healthcare purchasing decisions. Employers worry about upsetting their workforce, particularly when moving away from a familiar insurance company to a smaller, independent administrator. They assume that a recognized name on an insurance card provides some protection against employee dissatisfaction.

I understand the concern. No employer wants employees arriving at the HR department with medical bills they don’t understand or stories about problems at the doctor’s office. But after many years in this business, I have come to believe that employers often pay a considerable premium to avoid complaints without understanding what causes them.

And the causes are sometimes remarkably ordinary.

Where the Complaints Begin

Some years ago, I visited a hospital-owned physician for an orthopedic problem. At the doctor’s office, I was asked to produce my insurance identification card. Nothing unusual about that, by the way. After the appointment, I walked down the hall for another service, where I was asked for the same card.

Then I went to a third department, still on the same floor, at the same hospital, operating under the same electronic medical records system. Once again, someone needed my insurance card. I could practically see the other two desks from where I was standing.

This case clearly shows that much of the frustration employees associate with their health plan actually starts with the healthcare provider, often over minor issues that could be resolved right then and there.

The front desk is especially important. A receptionist accustomed to seeing Blue Cross cards may become confused when presented with a card bearing the name of an employer’s self-funded health plan. The provider network may be clearly identified on the card, but the unfamiliar name creates hesitation.

As a result – and since nobody seems to pay attention nowadays – the employee is told the office doesn’t recognize the insurance. Before long, HR hears that the new plan isn’t working.

Yet nothing about the employee’s coverage has necessarily changed. The problem may be nothing more than an unfamiliar card and someone at the front desk who doesn’t know how to process it.

These issues should be resolved promptly. But employers should understand the kinds of problems that may arise at the very beginning – which, by the way, do create noise. Trust me, BUCAs know that very well.

Employers should also ask themselves: Does that small issue really justify a 10%, 15%, 20%, or 30%+ overpayment on their healthcare plan? Most importantly, this should be part of the open enrollment conversation with employees: Do THEY consider higher deductibles and copays worth eliminating a one-time, 30-second conversation at the front desk about where the information is written on the card?

Replacing an entire healthcare arrangement because a provider’s receptionist has trouble recognizing an identification card would be an expensive solution to a rather small problem.

The Complicated Business of Paying a Bill

Billing is probably our largest source of employee complaints.

First of all, the first statement a patient receives from a hospital looks like a bill, but it mysteriously announces that it is “not a bill.” A few weeks later, an actual bill arrives. Meanwhile, the patient may have no idea whether the administrator has received the claim, whether it has been processed, or whether somebody is supposed to pay something.

A delay quickly becomes evidence, in the employee’s mind, that the insurance company isn’t doing its job. Sometimes a claim arrives without the information needed to process it properly. Sometimes eligibility must be verified with the employer. Occasionally the provider has submitted incorrect billing codes, and the administrator must go back and straighten things out.

Consider the confusion surrounding preventive care. An employee schedules an annual physical expecting certain services to be covered without cost-sharing. During the appointment, the physician also evaluates a separate medical complaint. That additional diagnostic service may be billed differently, and the employee is understandably surprised when a charge appears.

There are also cases in which a provider has coded a service incorrectly. We can contact the physician’s office, review what actually occurred, and have a corrected claim submitted when appropriate. These situations require investigation and explanation. An administrator should be willing to do both. But it would be a serious mistake to assume that every disputed bill is evidence of a defective healthcare plan.

The same principle applies to eligibility requirements. Some employers have rules concerning spouses who are eligible for coverage through their own employers. To administer those rules, we may need an employee to complete a simple attestation or coordination-of-benefits form.

We send notices. We send reminders. Sometimes months go by without a response. Then a claim comes in, and we cannot complete processing until the required information is provided.

Naturally, the employee complains that the claim has been delayed. But consider the alternative. If an employer establishes eligibility rules to control the cost of its health plan, should the administrator simply disregard those rules whenever somebody objects? That would make the rules rather pointless.

Friday Afternoon, 3:15

One of the more frustrating examples involves medical pre-certification.

We regularly encounter situations in which a patient has surgery scheduled for seven o’clock Monday morning, yet the administrator receives the first request for pre-certification at approximately 3:15 on Friday afternoon.

That leaves very little time to obtain medical records, review the proposed procedure, and determine whether the plan’s requirements have been satisfied.

Occasionally, we can resolve everything before Monday. Occasionally, we cannot.

The employee is then informed that the procedure may be delayed because the necessary approval hasn’t been obtained. Understandably, the employee becomes upset.

Who gets the complaint? Usually the health plan.

I have often questioned why requests arrive so close to the scheduled procedure. Whatever the explanation, the timing creates a problem that should have been addressed earlier. Healthcare expenditures include unnecessary services, questionable billing practices, and substantial differences in cost between otherwise appropriate treatment settings. An employer paying those bills has every reason to insist on reasonable clinical and financial oversight.

For example, certain infusions may be administered safely at home or in a hospital outpatient department, depending on the patient’s medical circumstances. The difference in cost can be several (sometimes 7x – 10x) times greater at the hospital.

Someone must be willing to ask whether the more expensive setting is medically necessary. That question may produce complaints, but avoiding it could leave all plan participants with a much larger bill.

The Employee Who Wants the Expensive Hospital

I remember an employer we worked with for approximately ten years who took a particularly thoughtful approach to healthcare spending. His organization saved well over a million dollars during that relationship, although some of the decisions responsible for those savings were initially unpopular.

He introduced arrangements that encouraged employees to use selected hospitals and physicians offering better economic terms. Employees who chose those providers paid less out of pocket. Those who preferred a more expensive facility could still use it, but they would contribute more toward the additional cost.

Naturally, some employees objected. His response was quite reasonable: You are free to choose the more expensive hospital, but the plan should not be expected to absorb every additional dollar simply because that is your preference.

Consider the circumstances of two employees. One is a senior executive with a generous salary who prefers a prestigious hospital across town. The other earns $50,000 a year, has a spouse working part-time, two children, and a household budget already stretched by ordinary living expenses. Why should the second employee help finance the first employee's preference for an expensive hospital when comparable, appropriate care may be available elsewhere at a much lower cost?

Take routine imaging. A particular MRI might cost a health plan $2,500 at one facility and $500 at another. Naturally, the services, clinical circumstances, and quality must be comparable. But when they are, the $2,000 difference deserves attention.

Now suppose the employer shares part of those savings with the employee by waiving out-of-pocket costs or reducing the employee’s contribution. In my experience, employees respond quite favorably when they can see a direct financial benefit from making a sensible healthcare decision.

Some people will continue to prefer the expensive hospital, and that is their choice. But the employee who would rather save money deserves a choice, too.

The True Cost of Silence

The financial consequences of these decisions have become difficult to ignore.

According to the 2026 KFF Employer Health Benefits Survey, the average annual premium for employer-sponsored family coverage reached $28,303. Employees contributed an average of $7,471 toward that amount. At smaller firms, the average employee contribution was $9,687, and nearly one-third of covered workers at those firms contributed $12,000 or more annually toward family coverage.

Now let me put that in terms an ordinary family can absorb financially.

Twelve thousand dollars a year is $1,000 a month BEFORE the family has paid a deductible, a copayment, or an unexpected medical bill. That is money unavailable for housing, education, retirement savings, or other necessities.

Now consider an employer that refuses to examine expensive provider arrangements, enforce eligibility requirements, or introduce sensible purchasing incentives because somebody might complain. Whose interests are being protected?

I have always believed that an employer-sponsored health plan is, in economic terms, a form of healthcare purchasing cooperative. The employer and its workforce share the financial consequences of how healthcare is purchased. In a self-funded arrangement, the connection is particularly direct because the employer pays the claims, and those expenditures influence the future affordability of benefits. Wasteful spending eventually comes at somebody’s expense.

The administrator’s responsibility is to see that claims are handled correctly and that the employer’s plan operates according to its established terms. At J.P. Farley, we are compensated for administration rather than rewarded for withholding claim payments. Delaying legitimate claims provides us no financial benefit. In fact, the longer a claim remains unresolved, the more administrative work and frustration it tends to produce. We would much rather pay a properly documented, eligible claim promptly than spend the following weeks answering telephone calls about it.

That does not mean every complaint should be dismissed. Employees can encounter genuine problems involving access to care, incorrect denials, provider billing, or administrative mistakes. Those concerns deserve immediate attention, especially when an employee’s treatment or finances are at risk. But a complaint should prompt an investigation before it dictates a policy decision.

A Better Conversation With Employees

I think employers underestimate how much their employees can understand when healthcare decisions are explained in practical financial terms.

Suppose an employer tells its workforce that certain hospitals cost considerably more for comparable services, that employees will receive financial incentives for choosing appropriate lower-cost alternatives, and that the savings are intended to help keep family coverage affordable. Do you think this conversation is worth having? I do.

Compare it with simply announcing that the company has renewed the same expensive plan for another year, that contributions have increased again, and that employees will have to pay their share. The second approach may produce fewer complaints during enrollment. It may also cost employees thousands of additional dollars over time.

Employers often worry that making changes will upset their workforce. I would suggest they also consider how many employees are already quietly dissatisfied with the amount deducted from their paychecks. Those employees may never complain to HR. They may simply accept that health insurance is expensive and that nothing can be done about it.

I have spent enough years in this business to know that something can frequently be done about it. It requires attention to the details of how care is purchased, how claims are processed, how providers are compensated, and how employees are encouraged to use their benefits. It also requires a little willingness to tolerate complaints while determining whether those complaints reveal genuine problems or merely reflect resistance to a different way of doing things.

An employer’s responsibility is to provide a health plan that serves its employees and manages their healthcare dollars responsibly. That responsibility occasionally requires unpopular decisions, followed by clear explanations and consistent execution.

After all, an employee may forget the inconvenience of having to explain an unfamiliar insurance card at the doctor's office. The money deducted from that employee's paycheck every two weeks is another matter entirely. And I would argue that protecting that paycheck is worth a little noise.
James Farley | J.P.Farley Corp
CEO | President

Initiate a Consultation

We invite employers and vendors who are uncompromising about the impact of their healthcare plans to schedule a strategic conversation.

Related Posts